I was recently asked by Crate&Barrel to host the ultimate cookie swap! I created a custom punch for the event and shared some of my favorite ways to package holiday baked goods for gifting. The turnout was amazing! I served over 20 gallons of my Pear & Orange Holiday Punch, wrapped over 1,000 cookies and had an audience of over 500 people!
A traditional cookie swap is simple: Invite friends and family, and have each person make enough of one kind of cookie to share. At the party you taste the treats, then trade and package them in creative and unique ways! Everyone leaves with finished gifts—and plenty of new recipes.
I have hosted many cookie swaps in my day and have some tried-and-true tips that will make your next party a success!
Start by sending out invitations to your guests, which should also explain the cookie swap concept.
Ask each guest to bring one kind of cookie and indicate how many dozen.
Create a theme to your party! Ask guests to bring all types of chocolate cookies, sugar cookies, or even decorated cookies.
Ask your guests to bring copies of the recipes to hand out at the party.
I like to make a small assortment of savory tea sandwiches to counteract the sweetness of the cookies.
Serve my Pear & Orange Holiday Punch!
Remember, be creative and have fun with the packaging supplies. I supply clear glycine bags, an assortment of holiday ribbons, and even food-safe paper shred. Stickers, seals, and labels are also great additions.
Cookie swaps are meant to be casual and social, do remember to play holiday music!
My BEST tip is, have FUN! This is also an event for you to enjoy!
The next time you host a cookie swap, incorporate my tips, tricks, and punch recipe to ensure a great time is had by all!
Pear & Orange Punch
Pear Nectar – 4 cups, bottled
Orange Juice – 8 cups, natural
Club Soda – 4 cups, cold
Orange – 1 whole orange, ¼-inch sliced
Rosemary – 5 sprigs, fresh, on stem
Cranberries – 1 bag, frozen, whole
Begin with well-chilled ingredients. First, pour the club soda into a large pitcher. Next pour the orange juice into the pitcher, and then the pear nectar. Stir gently.
Next, add the orange slices and whole rosemary sprigs to the pitcher, followed by the frozen cranberries. Stir the pitcher and allow the orange slices, rosemary, and cranberries to stay at the surface. Stir occasionally to keep the fresh juices well-mixed.
Provide punch glasses for your guests and enjoy the merriment!